ЖУРНАЛ ПРАВОВЫХ ИССЛЕДОВАНИЙСуванов Сардор Бахадирович2026
The US Pretrial System: Navigating the Balance Between Individual Liberty and Public Safety
PAGE NO. - · Individual Liberty · Public Safety · Dr. Amanda R. Caldwell
International Journal Of Law And Criminology · 05 · 2025
Аннотация
The United States pretrial system stands at a critical juncture, tasked with the dual objectives of ensuring defendants' appearance in court and safeguarding public safety. This inherent tension creates a complex landscape where individual rights, such as the presumption of innocence and the right to liberty, often intersect with societal demands for crime prevention and judicial efficiency. This article provides a comprehensive review of the US pretrial system, examining its foundational principles, the profound impacts of pretrial detention, and the persistent challenges of racial and ethnic disparities. It further explores the evolution of bail reform efforts, including the contentious introduction of algorithmic risk assessment tools, and their implications for fairness and equity. By synthesizing empirical evidence and legal analyses, this review highlights the intricate balance required to uphold constitutional protections while addressing legitimate public safety concerns, offering insights into ongoing debates and future directions for systemic improvement. Keywords: Pretrial System, Bail Reform, Pretrial Detention, Individual Rights, Public Safety, Racial Disparity, Algorithmic Risk Assessment, Criminal Justice. consequences, affecting employment, housing, family Introduction: The pretrial phase of the criminal justice stability, and even increasing the likelihood of system in the United States is a pivotal stage, conviction and future criminal activity [20, 21, 41]. determining whether an individual accused of a crime will be released into the community or held in In response to these concerns, a growing movement for detention prior to trial. This system is designed to serve pretrial reform has emerged, advocating for a shift two primary, often competing, objectives: ensuring the away from cash bail towards more evidence-based, defendant's appearance in court for subsequent risk-assessment approaches [22, 45]. Concurrently, the proceedings and protecting the safety of the rise of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and data analytics has community [3]. The tension between these goals is led to the development and implementation of profound, as upholding the constitutional presumption algorithmic risk assessment tools designed to predict a of innocence and the right to liberty for the accused defendant's likelihood of failing to appear in court or must be balanced against the state's interest in committing new crimes [34, 38]. While proponents preventing further crime and maintaining an orderly argue these tools can reduce bias and improve judicial process. efficiency, critics raise serious questions about their transparency, potential to perpetuate existing racial Historically, the US pretrial system has largely relied on disparities, and ethical implications [34, 52]. a monetary bail system, where defendants pay a sum of money or secure a bond to guarantee their return to This article aims to provide a comprehensive review of court. However, this system has faced increasing the US pretrial system, delving into the complexities of scrutiny for its disproportionate impact on low-income balancing individual rights and public interests. It will individuals and communities of color, often leading to examine the documented impacts of pretrial detention, prolonged pretrial detention for those unable to afford analyze the persistent issue of racial and ethnic bail, regardless of their flight risk or danger to the disparities, and critically assess the role of bail reform community [45]. Such detention can have devastating efforts and algorithmic tools in shaping the future of International Journal of Law And Criminology 1 https://theusajournals.com/index.php/ijlc International Journal of Law And Criminology (ISSN: 2771-2214) pretrial justice. By synthesizing empirical evidence and [9, 17, 18, 46]. legal scholarship, this review seeks to contribute to a For example, Demuth (2003) found that Hispanic and nuanced understanding of the challenges and Black felony arrests were significantly more likely to opportunities for creating a more equitable and result in pretrial detention compared to White arrests effective pretrial system. [17]. Demuth and Steffensmeier (2004) further Literature Review explored the intersection of gender and race-ethnicity, revealing that Black and Hispanic males and females The pretrial system in the United States is a critical faced greater disadvantages in the pretrial release component of the criminal justice process, aiming to process [18]. Cohen and Reaves (2007) reported that in balance the defendant's right to liberty with the large urban counties from 1990–2004, a higher community's right to safety [3]. This section reviews the percentage of Black (37%) and Hispanic (30%) felony existing literature on the impacts of pretrial detention, defendants were detained until case disposition issues of racial disparity, and the evolving landscape of compared to White defendants (21%) [16]. R
Доказательный фрагмент
«The United States pretrial system stands at a critical juncture, tasked with the dual objectives of ensuring defendants' appearance in court and safeguarding public safety.»
Образец извлечения
Демо-превьюThe United States pretrial system stands at a critical juncture, tasked with the dual objectives of ensuring defendants' appearance in court and safeguarding public safety. Полный текст публикации CiteX не хранит — доступ к первоисточнику открывается по DOI согласно лицензии издателя и выбранному плану.
- Цитирований
- 0
- Просмотров
- 0
- Тип
- Журнал
- Страна
- Узбекистан
- Ключевые слова
- Pretrial System, Bail Reform, Pretrial Detention, Individual Rights, Public Safety, Racial Disparity
Смежные источники
ЖУРНАЛ ПРАВОВЫХ ИССЛЕДОВАНИЙРозимова Кундуз Юлдашевна2026
ЖУРНАЛ ПРАВОВЫХ ИССЛЕДОВАНИЙХожаярова Нилуфар Немат кизи,2025
Междисциплинарный диалог науки и общества в эпоху экологических переменРЕФОРМИРОВАНИЕ АНТИКОРРУПЦИОННОГО, ФРАНЦУЗСКОЙ РЕСПУБЛИКИ +12026