Научные статьиM.H.Sayidova, S.U.Pulatova2025
COMPARING REPRESSION POLICIES IN TOTALITARIAN REGIMES: THE SOVIET UNION AND NAZI GERMANY
SOVIETUNIONAND NAZI GERMANY · Toshtemirova RaykhonZokirkizi · ScientificAdvisor:AbdurashidovAnvar Abdurashidovich (Department:History)
Международный мультидисциплинарный журнал исследований и разработок · 12 · 2025
Аннотация
This article presents a comparative analysis of the repression policies employed by two of the most infamous totalitarian regimes of the 20th century: the Soviet Union under Joseph Stalin and Nazi Germany under Adolf Hitler. Both regimes utilized systematic terror, mass arrests, forced labor camps, and executions toconsolidate power and eliminateopposition. Despite ideological differences—communism versus fascism—both states relied on similar mechanisms of control, including secret police, propaganda, and the criminalization of dissent. The study explores key similarities and differences in theirrepression strategies, their impact on society, and thelong-term historical consequences. Keywords: totalitarianism, political repression, Stalinism, Nazism, Soviet Union, Nazi Germany, gulag, concentration camps, mass terror. The 20th century witnessed the rise of totalitarian regimes that reshaped the political, social, and moral landscapes of entire nations. Among the most prominent examples were the Soviet Union under Stalin and Nazi Germany under Hitler. While driven by opposing ideologies— Marxist-Leninist socialism and racial-nationalist fascism—both regimes implemented brutal policies tosilence dissent, eliminateperceived enemies, and enforce ideological conformity. Repression in these regimes was not incidental but a fundamental element of governance. It was embedded in legal systems, institutionalized through state apparatuses like the NKVD and the Gestapo, and justified through elaborate propaganda campaigns. These regimes constructed enemies both real and imagined, turning internal purges and external conquests into tools of political survival and expansion. This paper investigates how Stalinist and Nazi repression policies functioned, comparing their methods, targets, and ideological motivations. By focusing on structural similarities and contextual differences, the article sheds light on how totalitarianism sustains itself through fear, surveillance, and systematicviolence. Theresearch applies a comparative historical analysis, using: Primary sources: Archival records, official speeches, secret police reports (NKVD, Gestapo), and legal decrees; Secondary literature: Scholarly works on totalitarianism, biographies of victims, and political science theory (Arendt, Friedrich & Brzezinski); Case studies: Purges of the Soviet intelligentsia (Great Terror, 1937–38) and Nazi persecution ofJews, political opponents, and dissidents; Conceptual framework: Based on totalitarian theory, state terror, and ideological state apparatus models. 591 INTERNATIONAL MULTIDISCIPLINARY JOURNAL FOR RESEARCH & DEVELOPMENT SJIF2019:5.2222020:5.5522021:5.6372022:5.4792023:6.5632024:7,805 eISSN:2394-6334 https://www.ijmrd.in/index.php/imjrd Volume12,issue06(2025) State Terror as a Tool of Power: Both regimes institutionalized terror. Stalin used the NKVD and show trials to eliminate political rivals and perceived “enemies of the people,” while Hitler’s regime employed the Gestapo and SS to persecute Jews, Communists, trade unionists, andothers. Use of Concentration and Labor Camps: The Soviet gulag and Nazi concentration camps functioned similarly as spaces for punishment, forced labor, and death. However, while gulags were primarily punitive and economic in nature, Nazi camps, especially extermination camps, hadagenocidal purpose. Ideological Justification: Stalin’s repression was framed around class struggle and counter- revolutionary threats, while Hitler’s was based on racial purity and anti-Semitism. Each regime demonized specific groups: kulaks and "Trotskyites" in the USSR, Jews and Slavs in Nazi Germany. Propaganda and Cult of Personality: Both systems heavily relied on propaganda. Stalin and Hitler were portrayed as infallible leaders, and repression was justified as necessary for national unityandsurvival. Impact on Society: Fear permeated everyday life. Citizens were encouraged to denounce neighbors and even family members. Public trust was shattered, and intellectual, cultural, and spirituallife was suffocated. Despite their ideological opposition, Stalinism and Nazism shared striking similarities in their mechanisms of repression. Both regimes viewed dissent as existentially dangerous and sought to prevent it through pervasive surveillance and violent coercion. The regimes criminalized thought, restricted personal freedoms, and used legal frameworks to justify extrajudicial killings andarbitrary imprisonment. However, key differences also emerge. Stalin’s terror was largely inward-focused, aimed at purging internal enemies within the Communist Party and broader Soviet society. In contrast, Nazi repression combined domestic control with externally directed racial genocide. The Holocaust represents a distinct form of totalitarian repression aimed at the total eradication of anentirepeople—a policywith noequivalent inStalinistpractice, despiteitsmass brutality. Anotherimportant distinctionis therole ofeconomic e
Доказательный фрагмент
«This article presents a comparative analysis of the repression policies employed by two of the most infamous totalitarian regimes of the 20th century: the Soviet Union under Joseph Stalin and Nazi Germany under Adolf…»
Образец извлечения
Демо-превьюThis article presents a comparative analysis of the repression policies employed by two of the most infamous totalitarian regimes of the 20th century: the Soviet Union under Joseph Stalin and Nazi Germany under Adolf… Полный текст публикации CiteX не хранит — доступ к первоисточнику открывается по DOI согласно лицензии издателя и выбранному плану.
- Цитирований
- 0
- Тип
- Журнал
- Страна
- Узбекистан
- Ключевые слова
- totalitarianism, political repression, Stalinism, Nazism, Soviet Union, Nazi
Смежные источники
Общество и инновацииKhosiyat MAMATKULOVA2024
Академические исследования в современной наукеKhudaiberdiyeva Arafat Israilovna, Ph.D Professor hudayberdiyevaarofat@gmail.com +12026
Научные статьиI.B.Yangiboyev, E.X.Berdanov +22025